We use cookies to analyze site traffic and improve your experience. Click Accept All to allow analytics cookies.

Privacy policy
Skip to content
James Allen Co logo white
(573) 334-3688 | info@jallenco.com
×
  • Home
  • About
  • Candidate
  • Jobs
  • Employers
    • Overview
    • Process
  • Services
    • Overview
    • Executive Search
    • Key Hire Search
    • Temporary Staffing
    • Temp To Full-Time
  • Contact
  • Blog

Loading job details…

Chief Financial Officer


Wooster, OH 44691 Full Time $200,000/year - $300,000/year Posted October 2, 2026 Active
  • Full Time

Job ID: 11946

Apply Now

Description


Vice President of Finance / Chief Financial Officer / Treasurer

Department: Accounting

Reports To: President

FLSA Status: Exempt




Position Summary




The Vice President of Finance / Chief Financial Officer / Treasurer is responsible for leading all accounting and financial activities of the organization. This individual provides strategic financial leadership and oversight across accounting, budgeting, investments, risk management, reinsurance, regulatory compliance, financial planning, and corporate governance.

The CFO works closely with the President, Board of Directors, senior leadership, external auditors, regulators, actuaries, bankers, and other business partners to support the organization’s strategic and financial objectives.




Key Responsibilities




Financial Leadership & Department Management
  • Lead and oversee Accounting, Risk Management, and Investment functions.
  • Establish departmental goals, policies, procedures, and performance expectations.
  • Ensure team members are appropriately trained, developed, and supervised.
  • Maintain succession planning for key departmental positions.




Financial Reporting & Analysis
  • Ensure accurate financial records and timely preparation of financial statements and reports.
  • Analyze key financial metrics and business trends.
  • Identify opportunities to improve financial performance, operating efficiency, and financial controls.
  • Provide financial analysis and guidance to leadership and individual business units.




Regulatory Compliance & Internal Controls
  • Ensure compliance with applicable insurance regulatory, tax, financial reporting, and accounting requirements.
  • Establish and maintain appropriate internal accounting controls.
  • Ensure financial data is complete, accurate, and appropriately safeguarded.




Corporate Planning & Budgeting
  • Coordinate development of the annual corporate plan and assist with presentations to the Board of Directors.
  • Manage the annual operating and capital budgeting process.
  • Oversee monthly budget variance reporting and analysis.
  • Assist departments in identifying opportunities to improve operations, reduce costs, and strengthen controls.




Strategic Planning
  • Partner with the President on long-term strategic and financial planning.
  • Evaluate financial strategies designed to strengthen the organization’s financial position.
  • Participate in the evaluation and due diligence of potential mergers, acquisitions, and other business opportunities.




Investments
  • Develop and oversee the organization’s investment policy.
  • Establish appropriate asset allocation targets.
  • Ensure the investment strategy aligns with the organization’s overall business strategy and risk tolerance.




Loss Reserves
  • Coordinate loss and loss adjustment expense reserve reviews with outside actuaries, auditors, and regulators.
  • Serve as a key contact for reserve-related inquiries.
  • Chair the internal Reserve Committee and ensure reserving practices remain consistent with approved policies and targeted reserve margins.




Reinsurance
  • Negotiate, administer, and regularly evaluate the organization’s reinsurance program.
  • Evaluate reinsurers and program structure to ensure alignment with the organization’s business strategy and risk profile.
  • Work closely with leadership and the Enterprise Risk Management Committee regarding reinsurance strategy.




Enterprise Risk Management
  • Establish and oversee the organization’s overall enterprise risk management framework.
  • Develop risk metrics and methodologies for identifying, evaluating, and monitoring risk exposures.
  • Chair the internal ERM Committee and communicate key risk matters to the appropriate Board committee.
  • Participate in other organizational committees related to operating risk, loss reserves, pricing, employee benefits, and retirement plans.




Corporate Insurance
  • Negotiate and administer corporate insurance programs, including D&O, fidelity bond, and commercial insurance coverage.




Tax Planning
  • Coordinate federal, state, and local tax planning.
  • Work with accounting and investment functions to identify appropriate tax strategies.




External Relationships
  • Manage relationships with external auditors, regulators, actuaries, bankers, and other financial partners




Corporate Governance
  • Attend Board and committee meetings as a member of management.
  • Provide financial analyses, recommendations, and reporting to the Board.
  • Assist with committee charters, agendas, minutes, and governance documentation.
  • Monitor relevant NAIC developments and help maintain appropriate corporate governance policies and procedures.




Compensation & Retirement Plan Oversight
  • Maintain oversight of the organization’s deferred compensation plan.
  • Coordinate plan contributions and distributions with the organization’s recordkeeper.




Additional Responsibilities
  • Serve as a financial advisor to business units and senior leadership.
  • Participate in special projects and strategic initiatives as assigned by the President.




Supervisory Responsibilities

The CFO is responsible for goal setting, performance management, employee development, and compensation administration for accounting leadership, with ultimate responsibility for the overall accounting function.




Education & Experience
  • Bachelor’s degree in Accounting required.
  • Advanced degree in Accounting, Finance, Business, or a related field is preferred.
  • Minimum of 10 years of relevant industry experience.
  • Property & Casualty insurance industry experience strongly preferred.




Licenses & Professional Designations
  • CPA designation preferred
  • Insurance industry coursework or professional designations, such as CPCU, are a plus.



Skills & Qualifications
  • Exceptional leadership and people-management skills.
  • Strong business and financial acumen.
  • In-depth knowledge of accounting, finance, budgeting, and financial reporting principles.
  • Ability to analyze complex financial information and prepare financial reports, statements, forecasts, and projections.
  • Strong strategic planning and organizational skills.
  • Excellent analytical, problem-solving, and decision-making capabilities.
  • Demonstrated ability to negotiate effectively and manage complex or sensitive situations.
  • Strong written, verbal, and interpersonal communication skills.
  • Ability to manage multiple priorities and projects simultaneously.
  • Ability to motivate and lead teams while maintaining high standards for accuracy and quality.
  • Ability to develop and maintain productive relationships with business partners, regulators, auditors, Board members, and other stakeholders.
  • Apply Online
  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • X
  • Email

Skip the Search

Send us your resume, and we'll find the jobs that are the best match for you.

Don't Miss Out

Save a job alert and we'll email you when similar jobs are posted.

About Wooster, OH

Discover exciting job opportunities in the vibrant city of Wooster, Ohio, and unlock your career potential today! Nestled in the heart of Wayne County, Wooster offers a perfect blend of small-town charm and big-city amenities. With renowned landmarks like the Ohio Light Opera, Wooster's historic downtown, and the unique cuisine at local favorites like Broken Rocks Cafe, this area boasts a rich cultural tapestry for residents to enjoy. Embrace the thriving arts scene, catch a performance at the Wooster Symphony Orchestra, or explore the beauty of Secrest Arboretum in your free time. Join us in Wooster, a place where growth meets charm, and let your career flourish in this captivating region.

Meet Your Recruiter

Amy Simpson

Amy Simpson

View recruiter profile

James Allen Co emblem
Quick Links
  • Home
  • About
  • Candidate
  • Search Jobs
  • Employers
  • Services
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Site Map
Recent Jobs
    Director of Insurance Operations
    Anywhere
    Medical Malpractice Claims Representative
    Jacksonville, Florida
    Senior IT Business Systems Analyst
    Roslyn, New York

View All Jobs

From Our Blog
Why Top Insurance Talent Leaves, Even When They’re Paid Well 
The Leadership Gap Nobody Talks About: Preparing Your Next Generation of Insurance Leaders
The Cost of Staying Comfortable: When Growth Requires a Change
What Insurance Professionals Should Know About AI in Hiring

View All Posts

Contact
Address

649 Willowbrook Bend
Cape Girardeau, MO 63701

Phone

(573) 334-3688

Email

info@jallenco.com

Follow Us

2026 The James Allen Companies, Inc | Designed By: Recruiters Websites | Site Map

Candidate Login

Sign in or create a free account to save jobs and access them from any device.

Continue with LinkedIn Continue with Facebook Continue with GitHub Continue with X

or

Continue with LinkedIn Continue with Facebook Continue with GitHub Continue with X

or

Receive a one-time login link by email.

Autofill from resume

We suggested these details from your resume. Review and edit anything that looks off before saving. Contact fields update your profile; work and education entries are added (they do not replace existing ones).

Contact
Work history

No work history suggestions. You can add jobs on your profile.

Education

No education suggestions. You can add schools on your profile.